Carlisle, a historic city in Pennsylvania, offers a wide variety of dining experiences for every taste and preference. From classic American diners to more sophisticated international offerings, the local culinary scene promises to satisfy even the most discerning food lover. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, here’s a roundup of the best restaurants in Carlisle based on recent reviews and dining trends.

Redds Smokehouse BBQ

If you’re craving some authentic Southern barbecue, Redds Smokehouse BBQ should be at the top of your list. Located conveniently in Carlisle, this unpretentious spot serves up some of the best smoked meats in the area. From baby back ribs to beef brisket, every dish is infused with smoky goodness. The barbecue sauces complement the meats perfectly, making this a must-visit for any barbecue lover. While the ambiance is simple, the quality of the food speaks for itself​.

Hamilton Restaurant

For a more casual, family-friendly atmosphere, Hamilton Restaurant offers a great selection of American diner fare. Open from 6 AM to 9 PM, this diner is an excellent spot for any meal of the day. Known for its delicious hotdogs, including the signature “hotchee dogs,” Hamilton also serves other comfort food staples like lamb chops and crab cakes. It’s a cozy spot to enjoy a meal with loved ones, and the friendly service adds to its charm​.

Market Cross Pub & Brewery

If you love a great pub atmosphere paired with a fine selection of craft beers, Market Cross Pub & Brewery is a standout. The pub is named after the Market Cross in Carlisle, England, and reflects the town’s rich history. The menu includes both American and British classics, including hearty steak salads, fish and chips, and juicy burgers. The brewery offers a variety of local ales, making it a perfect spot for craft beer enthusiasts​.

Spoons Café

For health-conscious diners or those who prefer lighter, fresh meals, Spoons Café is a hidden gem. Located in Carlisle’s downtown art district, Spoons follows a farm-to-table philosophy, ensuring that every meal is fresh and made without chemicals or artificial processes. They serve homemade soups, sandwiches, and paninis, with a focus on wholesome ingredients. It’s a perfect choice for a healthy lunch or a casual breakfast​.

Momma Spriggs Restaurant

Another fantastic option in Carlisle is Momma Spriggs Restaurant, which has earned a reputation for its delicious comfort food. Offering a range of Southern and American dishes, this cozy restaurant serves up hearty breakfasts, lunch, and dinner. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic egg breakfast or a satisfying Southern-style meal, you’ll find plenty to love here​.

Hickory Ridge Restaurant

Hickory Ridge offers a family-style dining experience that is perfect for anyone looking for a warm and inviting atmosphere. Known for its Pennsylvania Dutch specialties, Hickory Ridge serves slow-roasted meats, fresh-cut fries, and homemade apple butter. Open daily from 8 AM to 9 PM, this restaurant is also known for offering catering services for special events, including weddings​.

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion

For an elevated dining experience, 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion provides a sophisticated setting with an impressive selection of American fare. Whether you’re in the mood for salmon, steaks, or traditional sides, the restaurant’s menu features high-quality ingredients and expertly prepared dishes. A great place for both casual and special occasions​.

Fiddlers Bar & Grille

For those who enjoy a lively bar setting combined with great food, Fiddlers Bar & Grille offers an exciting experience. Known for its friendly atmosphere, Fiddlers serves up a variety of American dishes, including burgers, seafood, and classic bar foods. The extensive drink menu, complete with cocktails, beers, and wines, adds to the fun, making it a great place to unwind with friends​.

Marcello Pizza & Ristorante

If you’re craving Italian food, Marcello Pizza & Ristorante is the place to be. This restaurant offers a blend of classic Italian dishes, from pizzas and pasta to more elaborate entrees. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting bowl of spaghetti or a wood-fired pizza, Marcello’s provides a satisfying Italian dining experience in the heart of Carlisle​.

The Pizza Grille

Another great option for pizza lovers is The Pizza Grille. This casual eatery serves up a variety of pizzas, pastas, and American classics. With an emphasis on fresh ingredients and great service, The Pizza Grille is a fantastic spot for a family meal or a quick bite​.

FAQs 

What are the best restaurants in Carlisle, Pennsylvania?

Carlisle is home to a variety of dining establishments, catering to diverse tastes and budgets. Some of the top favorites include:

Redds Smokehouse BBQ: A must-visit for barbecue lovers, known for its smoked meats and laid-back atmosphere.

Market Cross Pub & Brewery: Offers classic American pub food with an extensive selection of craft beers, perfect for casual dining.

Spoons Café: A favorite for those seeking fresh, farm-to-table meals, serving healthy and wholesome dishes.

Momma Spriggs Restaurant: Offers hearty American and Southern comfort food, popular for breakfast and lunch.

1794 The Whiskey Rebellion: A fine dining experience that features upscale American dishes and craft cocktails.

Are there vegetarian and vegan options in Carlisle?

Yes, Carlisle restaurants are accommodating to vegetarian and vegan diners. Many establishments like Spoons Café offer plant-based dishes and emphasize fresh, wholesome ingredients. Additionally, Market Cross Pub & Brewery and other local eateries often provide vegetarian-friendly options on their menus. It’s always a good idea to check with the restaurant beforehand or browse their menu online to ensure they meet your dietary preferences.

Is there any place for fine dining in Carlisle?

Yes, Carlisle offers fine dining options for those looking for a more upscale experience. One standout is 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion, which offers an elegant atmosphere and a carefully curated menu featuring American dishes with a gourmet twist. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a romantic evening out, this restaurant provides the perfect setting.

What is the best place for pizza in Carlisle?

If you’re craving pizza, Marcello Pizza & Ristorante is widely regarded as one of the best in the area. Known for its authentic Italian pizza, Marcello’s serves wood-fired pies with a variety of toppings, including classic Margherita and more adventurous options like prosciutto and arugula. The Pizza Grille is also another popular option for casual dining, offering both pizza and pasta.

Where can I find the best barbecue in Carlisle?

For barbecue lovers, Redds Smokehouse BBQ is a must-visit. With expertly smoked meats, including ribs and brisket, paired with flavorful sauces, this restaurant is highly praised by both locals and visitors alike. Momma Spriggs Restaurant also serves up some delicious Southern-style barbecue that is well-loved in the Carlisle area.

Conclusion

Carlisle offers a diverse range of dining experiences, catering to all tastes, dietary needs, and occasions. From barbecue joints like Redds Smokehouse BBQ to upscale dining at 1794 The Whiskey Rebellion, the city provides something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for casual comfort food, a fine dining experience, or family-friendly spots, Carlisle’s restaurants are sure to delight. Don’t forget to check out local favorites like Spoons Café for fresh, wholesome meals, or Hamilton Restaurant for a classic diner breakfast. Whatever you’re in the mood for, Carlisle’s food scene promises a delightful culinary journey.

To read more, Click Here.